Skip to content
Taiwa no FumenPractical methods for shared thinking

English edition: the full translation has not yet received an independent line-by-line review. Check the linked sources and method-specific limits before use. Japanese PDFs and videos remain labelled.

Return to session-plan results

User and citizen experience

Turn Participation Barriers into Alternatives

Identify barriers involving movement, speech, writing, viewing, and time, and decide equivalent ways to participate.

People
15–20
Session time
180 minutes
Format
In person

English session plan

Original program status: draft. Source safety category: Medium; this is not a guarantee of safety.

Preparation: More preparation. Facilitation team: Four roles, including someone with facilitation experience.

What this session can decide

Decide participation methods and support proposals for the session. Do not determine whether an individual has a disability, what their diagnosis is, or whether they need accommodation.

Outside its scope

  • Do not require disclosure of diagnoses.
  • Do not claim to represent people's needs fully when those concerned are absent.
  • Do not impose one participation method on everyone.

Primary caution: Do not require disclosure of diagnoses.

Before starting

Question and scope
Identify barriers involving movement, speech, writing, viewing, and time, and decide equivalent ways to participate. Before starting, state the subject and period covered in one sentence.
What this session decides
Decide participation methods and support proposals for the session. Do not determine whether an individual has a disability, what their diagnosis is, or whether they need accommodation.
Output recipient
The Recorder keeps the final participation-method and support-owner table. Specify needed support and the scope that can be provided, retaining Accept, Accept with conditions, and Refuse separately from conditions and alternatives. Proposing or adopting an alternative does not mean accepting the original request.
Participation and information boundaries
Explain the choices to pass, take a break, or leave. Keep personal information, confidential information, and attribute-based evaluation off the record surface. Assign Participant support separately.
Operating roles
Assign Lead facilitator, Recorder, Timekeeper, and Participant support before starting, and confirm who announces switching and stopping.
Next review
Decide a review date, permitted viewers, and the person responsible for the next decision on the participation-method and support-owner table.

Who takes responsibility

Lead facilitator

Protect the purpose and exclusions of Turn Participation Barriers into Alternatives and announce the start and end of each stage.

From before the start through the end

Recorder

Record the participation-condition requests, barrier situations and helpful support, and participation-method and support-owner table at each stage, then hand them to their recipients at the end.

From preparing record surfaces before the start through storage after the end

Timekeeper

Notify the Lead facilitator 3 minutes before each stage ends and when switching to breaks or buffer time.

At the start of every stage and 3 minutes before its end

Participant support

Receive requests to pass, take a break, leave, or check individually, and decide with the Lead facilitator whether resumption is possible.

From before the start through the end

Session flow

Minutes are measured from the session start. Method time, transition time, breaks and buffer are shown separately; they are not additional overlapping activities.

  1. 0–18 minutes

    Collect requests that make participation easier

    Method: What would make it easier for you to participate · 0–15 minutes. Transition: 15–18 minutes (3 minutes).

    Write requests about speech, writing, movement, breaks, and viewing individually. Do not ask for reasons or diagnoses; explain the choice not to submit items the person does not want to share. If they want someone else to read, they choose the reader, content, and audience. Keep the choice not to use a reader and not to share.

    Responsible: Lead facilitator; Recorder; Participant support

    Output: Participation-condition request list

    Handoff: Pass only authorised requests to the next stage, within the content and audience chosen by the person. Do not pass on requests they choose not to share.

    This stage may be shortened only in accordance with the stated conditions.

  2. 18–81 minutes

    Hear experiences of participation barriers

    Method: User Experience Fishbowl · 18–78 minutes. Transition: 78–81 minutes (3 minutes).

    People who choose sharing describe situations where participation was difficult and conditions that helped. Others do not rebut, advise, or diagnose; record only situations and conditions.

    Responsible: Lead facilitator; Recorder; Participant support

    Output: Barrier situations and helpful support

    Handoff: Pass conditions whose use the person has authorised to the stage for agreeing the scope of support.

    This stage is not marked as shortenable.

  3. 91–154 minutes

    Agree the scope of support provision

    Method: What I Need from You · 91–151 minutes. Transition: 151–154 minutes (3 minutes).

    Participants make specific requests for the methods they need. Organisers respond with Accept, Accept with conditions, or Refuse, recording conditions and alternatives in separate fields. Refusal can accompany an alternative; proposing or adopting an alternative does not mean accepting the original request. Record an owner and preparation deadline for support to be provided. If a requested method cannot be provided, stop the relevant activity and decide an equivalent alternative or a changed date.

    Responsible: Lead facilitator; Recorder; Participant support

    Output: Participation-method and support-owner table

    Handoff: Give the support-owner table to the organiser responsible and each person responsible on the day.

    This stage is not marked as shortenable.

What is retained and who receives it

Participation-condition request list

Owner: Recorder

Understand each person's chosen participation method, including through anonymous input. The person chooses the content and audience for sharing; do not add requests they choose not to share to the record.

Barrier situations and helpful support

Owner: Recorder

Connect an abstract accommodation list to actual situations.

Participation-method and support-owner table

Owner: Recorder

Specify needed support and the scope that can be provided. Distinguish Accept, Accept with conditions, and Refuse; record conditions and alternatives in separate fields. Refusal can accompany an alternative, and proposing or adopting an alternative does not mean accepting the original request.

Materials and setup

Material names, quantities, groups and handling instructions retain the fixed draft's original helper-derived guidance. Where a format is marked “Source material specification”, the entire bound English source material entry takes precedence over the old helper-derived format guidance. This format-only correction does not resolve other instruction or safety concerns. English names are not substituted into a Japanese-keyed lookup.

Everyday tools

Dark writing implements

Quantity: 1 per person

Format: Dark broad-tip pens or whiteboard markers

Check that ink flows and place them within participants' reach. Avoid pale-coloured pens.

Sheets to prepare by hand

Optional participation-support request card

Quantity: 1 card per person

Format: Sticky notes about 75 × 75 mm, or A4 copy paper cut into 4 pieces

Give out blank cards before starting. Participants write only the request they need; reasons, health, and family circumstances are not required. Explain the choices to write nothing or not to share. If someone else reads, the person chooses the reader, content, and audience; confirm that scope before reading.

Sheet separating speakers' words from observed facts

Quantity: 1 sheet per person in the outer circle

Format: A4 copy paper

Divide the work surface into 3 fields: words the person actually said, facts observed in the outer circle, and questions to check with the person. Write headings in text rather than relying only on colour.

Role-specific support table

Quantity: 1 sheet per role

Format: Source material specification: Support sheets organised by role (1 per role, approximately A3)

Source-bound format display correction; the other fixed helper-derived guidance is unchanged.

Before starting, write the role name, responsibilities, and times covered. Add the person's name only after the assignment is decided. For each request, record the response, conditions, and alternatives separately. Use Accept, Accept with conditions, or Refuse as the response; proposing or adopting an alternative does not mean accepting the original request.

Request cards

Quantity: 5 per role

Format: Sticky notes about 75 × 75 mm, or A4 copy paper cut into 4 pieces

Do not buy a special product; write Request at the top of paper pieces. If participants fill them in, use one item per card and handwrite needed headings before starting.

Request-response labels

Quantity: 1 of each response per request

Format: Sticky notes about 75 × 75 mm, or A4 copy paper cut into 4 pieces

Write Accept, Accept with conditions, and Refuse on separate pieces, preparing enough of each type. Distinguish them by written headings even when using the same colour.

Available at the venue

Inner-circle chairs

Quantity: For 5–7 people sharing their experience

Format: Chairs already at the venue; no new purchase needed

Use venue chairs rather than buying them. Before starting, check the number needed, routes, and wheelchair turning space.

Outer-circle chairs

Quantity: 1 chair per remaining participant

Format: Chairs already at the venue; no new purchase needed

Use venue chairs rather than buying them. Before starting, check the number needed, routes, and wheelchair turning space.

Setup for each method

What would make it easier for you to participate

  1. Instructions offering a choice of speaking to everyone or contacting the facilitator individually

User Experience Fishbowl

  1. An inner circle approximately 2 m in diameter where people sharing experiences can see one another's faces
  2. One outer circle at least 1.5 m away from the inner circle
  3. One entrance and exit opening

What I Need from You

  1. Tables where participants with the same role sit together (1 table per role)
  2. One whole-group support matrix with rows showing requesting roles and columns showing responding roles

When to switch or stop

Fallbacks

One or more people do not want oral sharing.

Let the person choose anonymous cards, reading by someone they choose, or not sharing. For reading by someone else, the person chooses the reader, content, and audience; confirm that scope before reading.

Method guide: What would make it easier for you to participate

Stop conditions

Explaining a diagnosis, disability, or family circumstances becomes a condition of participation.
Stop the demand for explanation and handle only the participation methods needed.
The event is about to continue without providing a requested method.
Stop the relevant activity and decide an equivalent alternative or a changed date.

Sources, rights and limits

This site has composed this programme's purpose, connections between methods, facilitation, roles, outputs, and switching conditions. See each method's individual page for its sources and licence.

Original source records and their required notices are retained below. Their presence does not mean a new legal or cultural-safety clearance. Original citation titles are kept in their source language.

Sources and required notices for the 3 methods used

What would make it easier for you to participate

  • Source: Seeds for Change Facilitation Tools: What would make it easier for you to participate | https://www.seedsforchange.org.uk/tools | anti-copyright adaptation; changes made
  • Source: Conditions for applying anti-copyright | https://www.seedsforchange.org.uk/resources | anti-copyright
  • Attribution: Taiwa no Fumen Editorial Team | This site's text and diagrams
  • Cultural caution: This manifest contains no structured cultural-safety assessment. A person checks context, the option to decline participation, and power differences.
  • Limits of this record: Only the notices displayed in the public YAML were transcribed. No claim is made that individual rights do not exist.

User Experience Fishbowl

  • Source: Liberating Structures Fieldbook (2026): User Experience Fishbowl — Henri Lipmanowicz / Keith McCandless / Nancy White | https://www.liberatingstructures.com/user-experience-fishbowl | Adaptation under CC BY-SA 4.0; changes made
  • Source: CC BY-SA 4.0 | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
  • Attribution: Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless; Keith McCandless and Nancy White | Original-source author and contributor credit
  • Attribution: Taiwa no Fumen Editorial Team | Japanese adaptation and this site's own diagrams
  • Changes and adaptation: Adapted as a Japanese facilitation score; changes made
  • ShareAlike: Provided under CC-BY-SA-4.0
  • Cultural caution: open-method screening complete: No closed, ritual, or sacred cultural practice is used as a source; declining participation, sensitive information, and power differences are addressed in each method's limits and branches.
  • Limits of this record: Adapted with changes as a Japanese facilitation score under CC BY-SA 4.0 and provided under the same licence. Only the current page is covered; material from June 2026 or earlier, official icons, and third-party material were excluded.

Current-page credit and licence companion for this method

What I Need from You

  • Source: Liberating Structures Fieldbook (2026): What I Need from You — Henri Lipmanowicz / Keith McCandless / Nancy White | https://www.liberatingstructures.com/what-i-need-from-you | Adaptation under CC BY-SA 4.0; changes made
  • Source: CC BY-SA 4.0 | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
  • Attribution: Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless; Keith McCandless and Nancy White | Original-source author and contributor credit
  • Attribution: Taiwa no Fumen Editorial Team | Japanese adaptation and this site's own diagrams
  • Changes and adaptation: Adapted as a Japanese facilitation score; changes made
  • ShareAlike: Provided under CC-BY-SA-4.0
  • Cultural caution: open-method screening complete: No closed, ritual, or sacred cultural practice is used as a source; declining participation, sensitive information, and power differences are addressed in each method's limits and branches.
  • Limits of this record: Adapted with changes as a Japanese facilitation score under CC BY-SA 4.0 and provided under the same licence. Only the current page is covered; material from June 2026 or earlier, official icons, and third-party material were excluded.

Current-page credit and licence companion for this method

Confirmed programme clarification

The user confirmed the current programme text and programme-specific material instructions. Original methods, quantities, timing and print diagrams are unchanged. Earlier fixed notes are retained below as historical notes; they are not removed or treated as independently resolved. User confirmation of programme wording is distinct from independent acceptance of its English translation, rendered screens, rights and release checks.

Historical fixed-draft notes

The original fixed draft notes are retained without deletion as historical records of those fixed source versions. Current material format corrections are separately identified above; these notes do not imply that other concerns have been resolved.

  • The fallback allows proxy reading without explicitly restating the person's sharing permission. The stage handoffs restrict transfer to authorised requests and conditions; no additional permission for proxy disclosure has been inferred.

Japanese resources and historical source records

Original Japanese plan and its print view · Japanese operation pack or starter materials

An English print edition is not provided here. The linked plans, print views and operation materials are Japanese resources.

Historical recorded publication holds

The following original hold statements are retained verbatim with their fixed source versions. They are not a statement of current acceptance, nor does this historical label resolve a source-specific restriction.

  • English translation and rendered-page independent acceptance pending
  • Method dependency source/text SHA binding and current source-specific rights verification pending
  • Publication not cleared
Historical fixed-source and English-draft provenance

Japanese program SHA-256: d81ec340b4856114dcbe0095b831502386f8fbcae027167ac485b2a91c1c43c1

Fixed source context SHA-256: 8934b02a298ff8dc772785b186ed146130d80e069502c0a3580738380ad751cb

English draft SHA-256: 9517e55aa64ef9690eb6a9e75fbddce172ce87e70296553db31dcf2a70238b93

  • seeds-participation-needs: source c6454c63d04e17d2f20d6178720e4111bc7f595cf517ca53ca9b756f7a497bea; English draft 0c6c0403f0b47127bcb05c4383859accfdf3ab25d591c61a687600a7ebb51fb0
  • user-experience-fishbowl: source 014143e2729babfd2b77ce5f9b600f19f6fda1427ba56e24040b3dce1ef13b4a; English draft 94891ef9de1f23998206bcbbfc52ac6afea47790e59877d5c2e564478ae3067d
  • what-i-need-from-you: source 401074d95d75eb10f53f8845c0978a8b5f4275a96395e8366a1879a943505671; English draft 6b32fb0220d3476d53591ebaa2bac246e575bcc590438d146dc048928bd4215f

These hashes identify the checked inputs; they do not grant independent acceptance or publication clearance.